Friday, November 14, 2025

Woe, Is Me - I Want to Run Fantasy

So, there's this guy I know...

He really doesn't like Medieval Fantasy of the type you see in Fantasy RPGs like Dungeons and Dragons. He really doesn't like the game mechanics the majority of Dungeons and Dragons style RPGs use to facilitate running campaigns in that genre. At the same time, he really, really wants to run a Medieval-ish / Sword & Sorcery-esque Tabletop Roleplaying Game campaign.

Me. I'm that guy.


Beginning next year, I plan on running a [vaguely] Medieval Fantasy RPG campaign with the intent of making it a fairly long term mainstay for one of my groups. 

No, you read that right. No, this isn't a practical joke, I haven't gone mad, nor am I a Parallel Earth doppleganger of Adam from some twisted Mirror Universe. I just...let me explain..

I am Feeling Inspired

There are a lot of reasons for this including but not limited to: 

  • I haven't run an ongoing Fantasy campaign for a while and I’m feeling nostalgic.
  • I've been inspired by a blog project I am working on to appear early next year.
  • I've been inspired by other bloggers discussing Dungeons and Dragons and it makes me what to do something different.
  • I've been inspired by various Fantasy Anime, Manga, and RPGs. 

I Love a Challenge

I've had a great year running and playing Ghostbusters, the Wizarding World, Smurfs, Star Trek, Star Wars, and various Superhero games. All things I'm [generally] good at. I can reliably, more often then not, create a good time for my friends and I playing and Gamemastering these genres, settings, and games. 

Fantasy is not so easy for me. It requires a lot more thought, creatvity, research, and patience. Patience with the game, the genre, the players, and myself. The toughest part is always keeping myself interested. 

I really want to give it a go though. It's been a while since a have in a long term, open world fashion the way I once did.

I also want to find or create a system for running this type of game that I don't despise*

I Have Some Ideas

I actually have some thoughts on what would make for good 'adventures' or rather, NPCs and happenings going on in a Fantasy world. Many of my ideas are still in the early stage and will need some fleshing out before 'going live'. 

I also need to see what kind of characters the players come up with, as I usually try to intergrate the PCs into the world, the world into the adventures, and therefore the adventures into who the PCs are and what they're all about. 

I'm Driven By Spite (In a Good Way)

I must admit that I have a negative personality trait that makes me want to do a thing after encountering or experiencing that thing and thinking 'that could have been better'.Few things get me as fired up about running a particular game as finishing a bad game and believe it could have been really good.

That said, its not like I've been in any bad Fantasy games lately. In fact, I participated in a short, good one not long ago. Fun as it was, it ended up feeling just like every other Fantasy game and the rule mechanics of the RPG, while functional, eventually felt a little flat. I also vastly prefer running Fantasy to playing it [unless we're talking Smurfs, which I find really fun to play]. 

Then there are all the blog posts out there talking about the various incarnations of D&D. Each one I read makes me want to do it differently, do it my way, and to veer away from the kind of things that made me grow to dislike D&D in the first place. 

I know, it's a terrible reason to want to run a game but sadly it often works for me.

That's it for now. I'll probably be discussing this on and off again as we approach 2026 and the launch of whatever this ends up being.

Later days,

AD
Barking Alien

*OK, that's a little hyperbolic. I don't despise all Fantasy games. Just ones with Classes, Levels, Hit Points, Miniature/Wargame Based Combat, Treasure Based Experience, and Inflexible and Uncreative Magic.

So...a lot of them. 




7 comments:

  1. I'm very much not a D&D person either, but of late I've had an itch to play in Glorantha and I really want to give Break!! a try too.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Always like the Glorantha setting. Very well worked out and quite interesting.

      I tried Break!! and it was cool but not exactly what I'm looking for. Combat is quick but almost too quick, which is a strange things to hear coming from me. The cover overall struck me as Old School where I wanted it New and New School where I prefer the Old way if that makes any sense. Obviously YMMV and I only had a two session playthrough.

      Delete
  2. Hi Adam,
    You should have a look at Harnmaster. No classes, no levels, no hit points (just wound levels). Experience by practicing (a bit like Runequest).
    Only issues the magic system is specific to the universe (you'll have to adapt it) & it can be quite lethal if you are lightly armored.
    Damage depend on your weapon (fixed value) and how well you did succeed and your opponent failed (xd6).
    Even if it isn't the right system for you, there might be a few idea to poach.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have looked at Harnmaster, though not in a great many years. As you note, though the system isn't for me it has some excellent ideas and the world-building was quite good.

      Delete
  3. Yo Adam...so I realize the most cliche thing to post here is a "Have you checked out...?" suggestion (no shade intended toward anyone else taking the same approach), BUT...have you looked at Tim Snider's FIE, I SAY!...? It's WEG Ghostbusters shaped into a fantasy mold, and your experience tweaking GB to the style of you and your group may prove to have similar success here...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I...have not. O_O

      A game I haven't heard of that's similar to one of my favorites and you're 'selling it' on its customizable nature? Jonathan, you may have done the impossible! LOL

      I will definitely check that out. Thanks so much!

      Delete
    2. Yeah man, I'd love to know what you think of it! I would imagine it's very much along the lines of what you would have come up with if someone had tasked with with turning GB into a fantasy game, but it's still nice to see it all laid out AND have confirmation that it works...

      Delete